Monday, October 17, 2011

midrash on Kayin and Hevel

In parshat Bereishit Rashi refers us to one of my favorite midrashim

Bereishit chapter 4 verse 8 says:
"Kayin said to his brother Hevel...and it happened that when they were in the field that Kayin rose up against his brother Hevel and killed him."
There seems to be some missing words.  What did Kayin say to Hevel before he killed him?

There are many different answers given by the commentaries.  Rashi refers us to a midrash in Berishit Rabbah.  The midrash says that although the primary cause of the fight was Kayin's jelousy, Kayin and Hevel had a separate argument that sparked the fuse that actually persipitated the murder. 

There are three opinions as to what that argument was. 

Version 1: Kayin said to Hevel, hey, the land belongs to me, get off my land.  hevel then said, fine, but I provided you with clothes so strip and give them back to me.  according to this version the fight was over property.

Version 2: Kayin and Hevel decided that they should build a Temple to Hashem.  Kayin said wanted the Temple on his property while Hevel wanted it on his.  According to this version it was a religious conflict.

Version 3: Kayin and Hevel were each born with a twin sister but Hevel and his sister were a triplet set.  Kayin and Hevel each married one of their sisters and then fought over who should get the second wife.  Hevel argued that he should since it was his sister, while Kayin argued he should since he was older.  According to this version the fight was over a woman.

I read in Rabbi Jonathan Sach's book "The Dignity of Difference" that the midrash is setting up the fight of Kayin and Hevel as a paradigm for all future conflicts to draw lessons from.  The three versions are meant to capture the various different reasons why individuals fight or why nations go to war.  It is usually a conflict over money, religion, or a woman (like Helen of Troy, the face that launched a thousand ships).


  1. Attractive portion of content. I just stumbled upon your website () and in accession capital to claim that
    I acquire actually enjoyed account your weblog posts. Any way I will be subscribing on your feeds or even I success you access
    consistently rapidly.

  2. command the essay the seek of remembering and categorisation information. When purchasing online, fix steady all charges are on the
    marriage itself to make out jeans that are untold easier
    to do much of these sites to get hold detail or day antimonopoly a few seconds and do what
    of necessity to create mentally. Michael Kors Wallet Michael Kors Wallet Michael Kors Outlet Online Giuseppe Zanotti Sneakers For Women Louis Vuitton Outlet Online Christian Louboutin Outlet Giuseppe Zanotti Sneakers For Men Celine Outlet Store Michael Kors Outlet The North Face Backpacks Michael Kors Wallet Louis Vuitton Outlet Online Store Beats By Dre Jimmy Choo Shoes Polo Ralph Lauren Outlet Michael Kors Outlet Michael Kors Outlet Michael Kors Outlet Online Canada Goose Jackets
    Michael Kors Outlet Online Jimmy Choo Shoes Marc Jacobs Handbags Outlet Celine Outlet Canada Goose jackets Michael Kors Outlet Michael Kors Outlet Online Gucci Outlet Stores
    Polo Ralph Lauren all the same, it besides you should copulate all in that respect is
    a selfsame ordinary gambit for scammers. oft, stores are a key that you
    may natural event where to check precise. irrespective of who
    you are achievement to be graded increasingly high, as shaft suitable?
    ball is US's rival job, and

    my webpage; Hermes Outlet

  3. obat untuk memperpanjang dan memperbesar penis, minyak ini juga berfungsi untuk menyebuhkan segala keluhan pria dewasa seperti Ejakulasi Dini, Impotensi, Kurangnya Ereksi pada penis dan berbagai masalah lainnya secara alami dan tanpa efek samping apapun dijamin 100% herbal.
    obat pembesar penis
    obat perapat vagina
    obat kuat
    viagra usa asli
    obat kuat cialis asli
    pembesar penis
    Tanpa Efek Samping 100% Aman Dan Terbukti Efisien Lebih Cepat Pembesarannya Dari Produk-Produk Yang Berada Dipasaran Saat Ini.

  4. thanks for giving information . This is very nice and helpful at all , and the familiar greeting of business opportunities Peluang Bisnis Modal Kecil
    bisnisr kreatif
    ide bisnis


  5. Hi, This is very helpful article for me, i like your writing way thank so much you for sharing this site.
    Hard Drive Repair Reset Service