Sunday, February 12, 2012

Daily Business Ethics Halacha #17

Question: When evaluating whether an ambiguous, or possibly misleading statement is geneivat da'at does the Torah use reasonable-man standard or ignorant-man standard?

Rabbi Levine posits that the Torah uses reasonable man standard.  He derives this from a number of sources.

A case in messechet Hullin 94a:

Mar Zutra was traveling from Sikara to Mahoza while Rava and Rav Safra were going to Sikara.  They passed each other on the way and Mar Zutra thanked the Rabbis for coming out to greet him.  He assumed that the purpose of their trip was soley to show him honor. 
Rav Safra said, "We had no idea you were coming." 
Rava said to Rav Safra, "You did not have to tell him that."
Rav Safra said back, "but then we would be deceiving him."
To which Rava replied, "No we would not.  He would be deceiving himself."

Rabbi Levine posits that since it was unreasonable for Mar Zutra to expect that the others came all taht way to meet him they had no responsibility to correct him.  If theoretically it would have been reasonable that the Rabbis had come then they would have to correct him.

2 comments:

  1. A majority of diver's different watches apply the same kind of treatments plus find themselves wanting breitling replica indistinguishable together, Bell & Ross includes with success picked up heli-copter flight crushed avenue featuring its BR02. Swimming pool is important of your instance is definitely similar to all those for any Space or room 3 : an example of Bell & Ross' initially styles, a bed that appeared to be mind you as well researched by Look at Viewer. As a consequence of it has the shape, so would make a look at glance robust without the need of being fat and also massive to the hand. A BR02 is rather an individual look at: the form due to its call plus possession functions precisely the same tag heuer replica sale aeronautical design and style which will empowered a BR01, they usually the fact is glance just like people came out instantly originating from a killer plane's piece of equipment -panel... The following opinion is definitely further more a strong by cushion PVD release of your look at : your precious metal release of your unit (a BR02 Precious metal) is likewise out there, which includes a three-hand arrangement as well researched by Look at Viewer listed here. A further exceptional aspect of your look at is definitely it has the rotating ınner bezel, allowing so a wholly simple look and feel. By using a lot of famous brands owning little by little went from the such type of thought, it is really helpful so that you can hublot replica sale believe that it is listed here together with your diver's look at which includes a present day style and design. A good and bad points of your procedure inside of a getting problem is going to primarily often be reported by each one personal very own priorities plus patterns.

    ReplyDelete